Tau Topics: An Eclectic Franciscan Website

Home

Butter Side Down Blog

Follow Judy on Twitter (QuackersNCheese)

Disinfection with Vinegar and Hydrogen Peroxide

Toenail Fungus Case Study

Fly Control for Horses

Lab Test Accuracy

Risk, Rabbits and Raisins

DDT "Ban" and Malaria Deaths

Challenges in Finding Safe Building Materials for the Chemically Injured

Corn Gluten Herbicide

Weed Control Ideas

Ick! Lice!

Peanut Allergy
Op-Ed


Bona Fide Organics

Contact Us

Disinfection
Vinegar and Hydrogen Peroxide as Disinfectants
Copyright © March 1999 Judy Stouffer. All rights reserved.
This article may not be copied or published anywhere, including in any electronic format,
without specific permission from Judy Stouffer, B.S., M.S., OFS.

Bottle of White Vinegar

You can make your kitchen a cleaner, safer place and fight bacteria, without exposing yourself and your family to toxic chemicals that also damage the environment. You can use a simple safe disinfecting spray that is more effective than any of the commercial cleaners in killing bacteria. As a bonus, it is inexpensive!

Susan Sumner, a food scientist at Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, worked out the recipe for just such a sanitizing combo. All you need is three percent hydrogen peroxide, the same strength available at the drug store for gargling or disinfecting wounds, and plain white or apple cidar vinegar, and a pair of brand new clean sprayers, like the kind you use to dampen laundry before ironing. If you're cleaning vegetables or fruit, just spritz them well first with both the vinegar and the hydrogen peroxide, and then rinse them off under running water.

It doesn't matter which you use first - you can spray with the vinegar then the hydrogen peroxide, or with the hydrogen peroxide followed by the vinegar. You won't get any lingering taste of vinegar or hydrogen peroxide, and neither is toxic to you if a small amount remains on the produce. As a bonus: The paired sprays work exceptionally well in sanitizing counters and other food preparation surfaces -- including wood cutting boards. In tests run at Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, pairing the two mists killed virtually all Salmonella, Shigella, or E. coli bacteria on heavily contaminated food and surfaces when used in this fashion, making this spray combination more effective at killing these potentially lethal bacteria than chlorine bleach or any commercially available kitchen cleaner.


Bottle of Hydrogen Peroxide

The best results came from using one mist right after the other - it is 10 times more effective than using either spray by itself and more effective than mixing the vinegar and hydrogen peroxide in one sprayer.

Reference note: Articles on Dr. Sumner's original research work appeared in the scientific news journal, "Science News," in the issues that were published on August 29, 1996, and on August 8, 1998.

Author's note, updated February 2008: The question I get asked most by readers is, "Can I mix the hydrogen peroxide and vinegar into one sprayer?" The short answer is:  EEK - No!   The longer answer is:   never mix hydrogen peroxide and vinegar together in one container. The resulting chemical, peracetic acid, can harm you when mixed together this way if you accidentally create a strong concentration in this fashion. Peracetic acid also has entirely different characteristics and properties than either hydrogen peroxide or vinegar. Additionally, we don't know if peracetic acid kills the same group of pathogenic food-borne bacteria when used this way as a spray - it very well may not.

MiniFAQ: The questions we get asked the most about this article, with answers.

  1. Can I use apple cider vinegar (or rice vinegar or some other type of vinegar than white distilled vinegar)?

    Answer: As far as I know using apple cider vinegar or any other vinegar works the same as the white distilled vinegar -- no better and no worse.

  2. Do I have to dilute the vinegar?

    Answer: In the United States, the vinegar you buy at a grocery store for use in cooking or in salad dressings is already diluted and ready to use in the way this article describes. The bottle will say on the label somewhere "5% acidity." In other countries, check the vinegar bottle's label and make sure that the vinegar you are buying is already diluted so that it is only 5% acidity.

  3. Isn't spraying hydrogen peroxide and then spraying vinegar right after each other the same as mixing them together and then spraying that solution?

    Answer: Absolutely not. Chemical reactions that occur in closed containers can be quite different than reactions that occur in open air. Hydrogen peroxide and any type of vinegar should especially never be combined in a closed container, like a spray bottle. You don't want to pour the two together in an open container either, but you absolutely never ever mix them in a closed container. Spraying them one after the other does not cause the same kind of chemical reaction that putting them together in a closed container can, or that (under the right conditions) might occur when pouring them together in an open container.

  4. This disinfection technique works because it's creating peracetic acid when you spray one after the other, right?

    Answer: No, not when you spray one, then the other, according to conversations I've had with the original researcher and other experts since then.

  5. Why do you make such a big deal about avoiding peracetic acid?

    Answer: Peracetic acid can be highly corrosive, and it is a "primary" irritant. It can permanently damage the lungs, and cause occupational asthma. It can also have other chemical properties depending on the concentration that make it quite dangerous in other ways as well.

Design, layout, graphics and contents copyright 1999-2015 Judy Stouffer. All Rights Reserved. The articles, graphics and images on this website may not be copied or published anywhere, including in any electronic format, without specific permission from Judy Stouffer, B.S., M.S., OFS

The pages on this website have been viewed millions of times by visitors from more than 140 countries since going online in March 1999.

Page last updated: February 11, 2015